Tocuro
Painted cast-iron Mulligan policeman bank in a blue uniform and derby hat, standing on a black shelf beside a cast-iron stake truck
FEATURED FIND

Mulligan the Cop Still Bank

A five-and-dime policeman bank that ended up in an art museum, plus how to spot a reproduction.

The short answer

Mulligan is a painted cast-iron still bank shaped like a policeman in a derby hat, with a nightstick and a coin slot in his back. The Minneapolis Institute of Art credits it to the A.C. Williams Company of Ravenna, Ohio, about 1905–1932. Some stores had their names cast on his back, turning a dime-store toy into a tiny billboard.

Item Details
Type
still bank
Category
Toys & Games
Designer
Unknown
Maker / Manufacturer
A.C. Williams Co.
Model / Series
Mulligan / Policeman, Moore #177
Date Range
c. 1905–1932
Style
Figural character bank
Region of Origin
United States
Materials
cast iron

What we spotted

A worn blue cast-iron policeman bank with a derby hat and nightstick on a black shelf against a yellow wall, next to an old cast-iron truck carrying a wrapped bale1234

Found by a Tocuro user. Their original photo.

  1. Derby hat. The museum example has a gold hat band. On this one the hat reads as worn, rust-brown iron with no gold left.

  2. Chipped face paint, with a red painted mouth. The flesh tone has flaked, showing dark iron in patches across cheeks and nose.

  3. Black nightstick. He holds it diagonally across his chest, as the museum record describes.

  4. Twine at the ankles and neck. Cord is wrapped around his legs and collar. It is not part of the bank as cast or painted.

What is the Mulligan the Cop bank?

A.C. Williams began in Chagrin Falls, Ohio, in 1886 and moved to Ravenna in 1893. Its toy line grew from model sad irons made for salesmen, and banks like Mulligan sold mainly in five-and-dimes such as Woolworth.

Each bank is two cast halves joined by one screw, with the coin slot in the back. Most wear a blue uniform, but gold-painted Mulligans exist too.

Why is it special?

  • A dime-store bank made it into a museum. The Minneapolis Institute of Art holds one, accession 2003.236.620, given by Katherine Kierland Herberger. Its record of size and paint gives a fixed reference for judging other examples.
  • Some Mulligans advertised local stores. Merchants such as 'Bennet & Fish' had their names cast in raised letters on the back. Cast-in store names are unusual and hard to find, so a plain back is the norm and a lettered one is the find.

How to tell an original from a modern reproduction

CheckA.C. Williams originalModern reproduction
ScrewOne flat-head slotted screwOften Phillips-head; some fakes use slotted
Casting surfaceSmooth, fine-sand finishGritty or pitted, flash at the edges
SeamsTight, halves line upGaps or misaligned halves
WeightFull cast-iron weightUp to about 30% lighter
PaintBlue, gold buttons and hat bandBright, with uniform or faked wear
See this find on TocuroItem details and market snapshot

Questions people ask

Who made the Mulligan the Cop bank?

The museum record credits A.C. Williams of Ravenna, Ohio. Some auction catalogs credit Hubley, about 1914, and no reliable physical feature separates the two castings.

What is the Moore number for the Mulligan bank?

It is #177 in The Penny Bank Book by Andy and Susan Moore, on page 71.

Is the Arcade policeman bank the same as Mulligan?

No. The Arcade Policeman came from Arcade Manufacturing in Freeport, Illinois, and is listed as Moore #182.

How tall is the Mulligan bank?

About 5 1/2 to 6 inches; the museum example measures 5 15/16 inches tall.

When did A.C. Williams stop making cast-iron banks?

The company made its last cast-iron toys and banks in 1937–1938, then carried on in other metalwork as Lite Metals.

Sources

  1. "Mulligan (or Policeman)" still bank, A.C. Williams Company (acc. 2003.236.620) — Minneapolis Institute of Art, 2003
  2. "Mulligan" Policeman Coin Bank – Cast Iron — Bargain John's Antiques, 2022
  3. Hubley Manufacturing Company Collectibles (Cast Iron Policeman Bank lots) — LiveAuctioneers, 2026
  4. A. C. Williams Toy Company – Guide to Value, Marks, History — WorthPoint, 2023
  5. Williams, A.C. (maker profile) — AntiqueToys.com, 2022
  6. Antique Cast Iron Still Coin Bank – Mulligan The Policeman – Bennet & Fish — Bargain John's Antiques, 2020
  7. Authenticating Old Cast Iron Toys and Banks — Midtown Mercantile, 2017
  8. Determining The Authenticity of Cast Iron — Pioneerthinking.com, 2026

By Tocuro Editors · Research checked 2026-11-08 · 3 min read

What's on your shelf?

Got a cast-iron bank like this one? Snap it with Tocuro to find out who made it and when.

IDENTIFY YOUR OWN